The questionnaire went out on a Monday to 150 suppliers. Three weeks later, twenty answers have arrived in four different formats, and nobody knows which ones count towards Scope 3. Supplier follow-up for carbon data rarely fails for lack of goodwill: everyone is chased in the same way, on poorly defined data, with no closing date.

This guide describes a method that works in any sector: rank suppliers by their weight in Scope 3, define the request, set a reminder schedule, measure the useful response rate and check the answers. It ends with the limit that European regulation now places on what you can ask of a company with 1,000 employees or fewer. The worked example is fictional and recalculated end to end.

Which suppliers should you chase first?

Chase first the suppliers that weigh most in your estimated emissions, not the ones you spend the most with. Ranking takes three steps.

1. Estimate before you ask. Apply a spend-based ratio (kgCO2e per thousand euros) to each supplier to get a first estimate. This screening is for ranking, not measuring, as the reference guide to Scope 3 points out. Keep its imprecision in mind: some spend-based ratios in the ADEME Base Carbone carry a published uncertainty of 80%, as detailed in the article on carbon footprint uncertainty.

2. Accumulate. Sort by decreasing emissions and compute the cumulative share. The GHG Protocol technical guidance illustrates the logic with a coffee company: ten suppliers out of a hundred account for 85% of the quantity of beans purchased, they are engaged with primary data and the result is extrapolated to the whole, while sugar, negligible in spend, is handled with secondary factors.

3. Adjust. The GHG Protocol also considers the influence you have, risk and stakeholder views. A mid-sized but responsive supplier can move ahead of a heavier one over which you have no leverage.

Worked example (fictional data)

A mid-sized company buys €48M from 180 suppliers. The screening, with fictional ratios, gives:

  • Supplier A: €6.0M × 500 kgCO2e/k€ = 3,000 tCO2e
  • Supplier B: €3.5M × 800 kgCO2e/k€ = 2,800 tCO2e
  • Supplier C: €5.0M × 300 kgCO2e/k€ = 1,500 tCO2e
  • Supplier D: €2.0M × 700 kgCO2e/k€ = 1,400 tCO2e
  • Supplier E: €8.0M × 100 kgCO2e/k€ = 800 tCO2e
  • Supplier F: €1.5M × 400 kgCO2e/k€ = 600 tCO2e
  • 174 others: €22.0M × 150 kgCO2e/k€ = 3,300 tCO2e

Estimated total: 13,400 tCO2e. The top six suppliers (3.3% of the 180) account for 10,100 tCO2e, 75% of emissions, for €26M, 54% of spend. E ranks first by spend but fifth by emissions. These six receive a primary data request; the other 174 stay estimated until the next inventory.

What should you ask for: primary data or an emission factor?

Ask for a defined object, in a set format, and only what you will use in the calculation. "Send us your carbon footprint" produces a company-level number that you cannot link to what you buy.

The technical guidance ranks the specificity of supplier data from best to weakest: product, then activity or production line, site, operational unit, company. Ask for the finest level the supplier can produce and record the one you get: that trace feeds your data quality disclosure. An effective request fits on one page and contains six elements.

  • The object: the footprint of the product you buy (kgCO2e per unit, cradle to gate) or, failing that, the supplier's Scope 1 and 2 emissions allocated to your purchase (the "supplier-specific" and "hybrid" methods).
  • The period: the reporting year, aligned with yours.
  • The boundary: what the figure includes and excludes, and the allocation method.
  • The unit and format: a fixed template, one field per data point.
  • The evidence: inventory, life cycle assessment, meter reading or signed statement.
  • The confidence level: method, and share of measured versus estimated data.

For a supplier who cannot produce anything of this kind, ask for physical quantities (tonnes, units, kWh) and apply an average-data emission factor yourself, see the article on emission factors. If your chain is deep, tiers 2 and 3 are covered for one specific sector in the article on tier 2 and tier 3 supplier emissions.

What follow-up schedule should you use?

Set a closing date for the collection, then work backwards. This schedule is a practical recommendation, not a standard: adapt it to the size of your suppliers.

  • D-7, announcement. The buyer warns that the request is coming, explains why and names a contact person.
  • D0, sending. Short message, template attached, 30-day deadline.
  • D+10, first reminder. Deadline reminder and answers to common questions.
  • D+20, second reminder. It comes from a human the supplier knows and offers a 20-minute call to fill in the template.
  • D+30, deadline. Suppliers without an answer move to "estimated" status with the method stated, not to "missing".

Never remind with the same text. For a partial answer, ask about the missing field rather than resending the whole request. Avoid year-end closing periods and holidays.

Sending, tracking and triggering reminders on fixed dates are repetitive: that is what gets automated. The D+20 reminder and the checking of answers call for judgement.

What response rate should you aim for, and how do you measure it?

We cite no benchmark response rate: a campaign is best judged on your own figures. Measure your campaign with two indicators.

  • Response rate by count: suppliers who answered divided by suppliers contacted. It drives the reminder workload.
  • Emissions coverage: estimated emissions of respondents divided by total estimated emissions. It drives the quality of the inventory.

In the example, four of the six priority suppliers answer (A, B, D, F), while C and E stay silent at the deadline. The response rate by count is 4 out of 6, or 67%. Coverage is (3,000 + 2,800 + 1,400 + 600) = 7,800 tCO2e out of 13,400, or 58%. Among the six priority suppliers, C and E remain estimated: 2,300 tCO2e, 17% of the total. The other 174 suppliers (3,300 tCO2e) also remain estimated.

Only coverage is disclosed: the Scope 3 Standard asks you to report, per category, the percentage of emissions calculated from data obtained from suppliers or other value chain partners. The next campaign therefore targets C (1,500 tCO2e) before E.

How do you check the quality of the answers?

An answer received is not validated data. Five checks, in order:

  • Unit and period: kgCO2e or tCO2e, per unit or in total, correct year.
  • Boundary: a cradle-to-gate figure is not comparable to one limited to direct site emissions.
  • Order of magnitude: compare with your estimate. A gap of a factor of three or more is a signal to explain, not a certain error. This threshold is a rule of thumb.
  • Allocation: does the figure cover what you buy or the supplier's whole activity? A company total has to be scaled to your share.
  • Evidence and double counting: is the source attached, and are these emissions not already in the Scope 3 of another supplier you collect from?

In the example, D answers 210 tCO2e against an estimate of 1,400, or 15%. Before accepting, ask whether the figure includes the materials D buys or only its Scope 1 and 2. In the second case, add the inputs (hybrid method) or keep the estimate until the boundary is completed. For each answer, record the specificity obtained, the source and the date.

What can you ask of a supplier with 1,000 employees or fewer?

For requests that feed a CSRD sustainability report, the directive as amended by Omnibus I (Directive (EU) 2026/470) creates a value chain cap: the reporting undertaking does not require protected undertakings in its value chain to provide more than the information specified in the voluntary standards. The content of that cap is set by Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560, published in the Official Journal on 21 September 2026, in force since 24 September 2026 and applicable to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. It covers only the data points listed in its Annex II.

  • Who is protected: any undertaking in the value chain that does not exceed 1,000 employees on average over the previous financial year, with no turnover criterion.
  • Right to refuse: the supplier may refuse to provide anything beyond the information specified in the voluntary standards. A contrary contract clause is not binding.
  • Your obligation: if you ask for more, flag what goes beyond the standards and remind the supplier of the right to refuse. Size is self-declared by the supplier, unless you know, or could reasonably be expected to know, that the declaration is manifestly wrong.
  • Your safe harbour: a reporting undertaking that stays within the cap is deemed compliant for its value chain.

The cap does not apply to due diligence or to purposes other than sustainability reporting, and it imposes no obligation to provide information on any undertaking in the value chain. A mid-cap with 1,200 employees, even outside the scope of the CSRD, is not protected.

The Annex II list is narrow. For an undertaking with more than 10 employees, it includes in particular total energy consumption in MWh and the estimate of gross absolute greenhouse gas emissions (requirements B3), as well as general and social information such as headcount. For an undertaking with 10 employees or fewer, it is shorter and does not include these energy and GHG data. A product-level footprint is not on it.

In practice, split your request into two blocks. The first is limited to the Annex II points. The second groups your management requests, such as product-level footprints, presented as optional with a mention of the right to refuse. The context of the voluntary standard is presented in our article on the voluntary standard. Member states must transpose the directive by 19 March 2027; this article describes the European texts.

How Kabaun automates supplier follow-up

Kabaun's supplier follow-up automation sends data requests as Scope 3 questionnaires, tracks responses and schedules reminders. It handles the mechanical part: who received what, who answered, who to chase and when.

On the control side, each data point is linked to a traceable source, supplier statements included. Uncertainty analysis displays the uncertainty intervals of the footprint following GHG Protocol recommendations, and the audit trail keeps changes, calculations and validations with timestamps. Choosing priority suppliers, the content of the request, the human reminder and the analysis of gaps remain decisions for your team. For the rest of the footprint, see the article on automating carbon accounting.

FAQ: supplier follow-up and carbon accounting

Which suppliers should you chase first for a carbon footprint?

Those that weigh most in your estimated Scope 3 emissions, not necessarily the largest by spend. Estimate with a spend-based ratio, sort by decreasing emissions and accumulate: the first names that cover most of the emissions receive a primary data request.

What data should you ask a supplier for Scope 3?

The footprint of the product you buy (kgCO2e per unit, cradle to gate) or, failing that, its Scope 1 and 2 emissions allocated to your purchase, with period, boundary, unit, source and confidence level. Without that, ask for physical quantities and apply an average-data factor.

How many times should you remind a supplier?

The proposed schedule has two reminders before the deadline: at 10 days, then at 20 days from a human contact, for a 30-day deadline. After that, move the supplier to estimation. This schedule is a practical recommendation, not a standard requirement.

What is a good supplier response rate?

We cite no benchmark rate. Track the response rate by count, which measures reminder workload, and emissions coverage, which measures the share of your Scope 3 calculated with supplier data. Only the second is disclosed.

How do you check that a supplier's answer is reliable?

Check unit, period, boundary, order of magnitude against your estimate, allocation and evidence. A gap of a factor of three or more must be explained before you accept the data.

Can you require carbon data from a supplier with 1,000 employees or fewer?

For a request made for CSRD sustainability reporting, it has the right to refuse anything beyond the information specified in the voluntary standards, whose cap is the list of data points in Annex II of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560, applicable to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. The cap does not apply to due diligence.

Conclusion

Effective supplier follow-up is prepared before sending: a ranking by weight in Scope 3, a one-page request, a dated schedule, two indicators and five checks on receipt. Automation takes over sending and fixed-date reminders; you keep the analysis. To see how Kabaun applies this method to your purchasing, contact the team.

Sources

  • GHG Protocol, Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standard and Technical Calculation Guidance.
  • Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560 of 3 July 2026 (voluntary standard), Official Journal of the European Union of 21 September 2026.
  • Directive (EU) 2026/470 (Omnibus I), Official Journal of the European Union, Article 19a of Directive 2013/34/EU as amended.